"Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark 2" Hits a Snag

By The Crypt Keeper · May 20, 2026 · 1 source
Passenger

Related Film

Passenger

The quick read

  • Director André Øvredal is ready to direct but needs a script.
  • "Scary Stories to Tell In The Dark" sequel faces development hurdles.
  • The sequel's forward momentum depends on script readiness.

André Øvredal, the director behind "Scary Stories to Tell In The Dark," has expressed his readiness to helm the sequel, according to a recent SlashFilm report. With the chilling world of Alvin Schwartz's tales primed for further exploration, Øvredal's enthusiasm is clear, but it comes with a caveat: the script isn't ready yet. The beloved book series, which scarred a generation with Stephen Gammell's macabre illustrations, provided fertile ground for 2019's adaptation, proving there's still flesh on this skeletal franchise for Øvredal to gnaw on.

The sequel's development appears to be at a standstill, hinging on the crucial next step of finding or finalizing a script. The first film found a sweet spot between nostalgia and creativity, with Øvredal bringing a respectful yet fresh vision to the tales. Guillermo del Toro's involvement as producer also provided a reassuring presence for fans. The sequel's challenge will be ensuring that it can expand on the folklore without sacrificing the eerie charm that made the original successful.

In the world of horror, which often thrives on quick turnarounds, this delay is not unusual but may be frustrating for those eager to see these ghostly stories continue. If the script can capture even a fraction of the uncanny allure of its source material, fans can expect a sequel that stands up to the genre's scrupulous devotees. For now, though, patience is the name of the game.

Sources

  1. Passenger Director Is Ready To Make Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark 2 — But There's A Catch [Exclusive] Slash Film · May 20, 2026

Story Timeline