The Theatre Bizarre (2011) movie poster

The Theatre Bizarre

2011 ·1h 54m · ★ 5.3 (115)

Down a seedy city street in her neighborhood, young Enola Penny is obsessed with what appears to be a long abandoned theatre. One night, she sees that the front door is slightly ajar and impulsively decides to sneak inside. But there in the dark, decrepit auditorium, a show unlike any other unfolds before her eyes. Its host is an eerie human puppet named Peg Poett who will introduce Penny to six tales of the bizarre: A couple traveling in a remote part of the French Pyrenees cross paths with a lustful witch; A paranoid lover faces the wrath of a partner who has been pushed to her limit; The Freudian dreams of an unfaithful husband blur the lines between fantasy and reality; The horrors of the real world are interpreted through the mind of a child; A woman addicted to other people's memories gets her fix through the vitreous fluid of her victims' eyeballs; And a perverse obsession with sweets turns sour for a couple in too deep.

Why it matters

A grotesque carnival of nightmares wrapped in a midnight movie anthology that revels in practical effects and unsettling atmosphere.

  • Six directors each spin a distinct, twisted vision, making it a kaleidoscope of horror subgenres from folk witchcraft to body horror.
  • Peg Poett’s eerie puppet hosting connects the segments with carnival macabre that recalls 70s and 80s anthology staples like *Creepshow* and *Tales from the Crypt.*
  • Practical effects and makeup by legends like Tom Savini and Robert Kurtzman elevate the grotesqueries beyond typical indie fare.
  • Not for the faint-hearted or narrative purists — the film’s uneven pacing and tone reward viewers craving a surreal, visceral horror buffet over cohesive storytelling.
2 horror films in catalog

Horror DNA

Gore
100
Slow Burn
66
Psychological
100
Supernatural
60
Creature
73
Disturbing
100
Fun Factor
67
Cerebral
99
Survival
83
Anthology

Content Warnings

Sexual ViolenceChild in DangerTaboo ContentBody HorrorEye TraumaDehumanizationTortureMedical Gore

Phobia triggers

Religious ImageryTight SpacesDolls PuppetsEyesMedical Procedures

Pairs Well With